Objections regarding some Incidents mentioned in Fadhail Durood in Fadhail A'maal.

Question ID: 
826

Question

Aslmkm.. In Fadhail Durood, p.97, Incident no (Hikayat) 35: The Messenger of Allah (allegedly) said: “Whoever wants something from anyone should go to his grave and supplicate to Allah for it.” Again on page 109, Incident number (Hikayat) - 48, Fadhail Durood (The last chapter in Fadhail ‘Amaal, Vol.I): “Sh. Abu Khair Qattah said that: I went to Madinah and stayed there for five days but did not achieve the pleasure and satisfaction. I went to the graves of the Prophet, Hadhrat Abu Bakr and Hadhrat Umar and said, “O Messenger of Allah I am your guest tonight.” Then I left the place and slept behind the minbar. I saw in my dream that the Prophet of Allah with Abu Bakr on his right, Umar on his left and Ali was in front of them all. Hadhrat Ali then shook me and said that the Messenger of Allah has come to visit me. I got up and kissed the Prophet between his eyes. The Messenger of Allah then gave me a piece of bread which I ate half and when I woke up the other half was in my hand.” What does Zakaria Kandalvi wants to prove through these evil fabrications. That making a supplication near the graves pays off by a visit by the Prophet himself and being awarded a piece of bread. And do things in dream last after the dream is over. No! but Zakaria Kandalvi wants to put the idea to his readers that the Messenger of Allah and those illustrious Companions visited Sh.Qattah in real life and not just a dream. someone sent me this and said these are the things we teach in masjids and do u think u people are on truth after reading this.. he also said there are many more he'll send me.. can u provide me with an answer? jzklh

Answer

Wa alaikumus salaam. Unless proven impossible by way of shariat,everything may occur or happen and is possible. There is no evidence in sharia that indicates that these kinds of incidents cannot take place.